| 4754 | 1 | Benjamin Charles Mitchell | | PO Box 70, Albert Town, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9344 (bcmitchell@me.com) | Inclusionary Housing Benjamin Mitchell - Affordable Housing Submission |
|
|
| 52238 | 1.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the plan change be rejected, and that the funding of social housing be considered as an election or referendum issue. |
| 52239 | 1.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the plan change be rejected, and that the funding of social housing be one that is equitable across all ratepayers. |
| 52240 | 1.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the plan change be rejected, and that a method for funding of social housing be selected which does not increase the cost of land and therefore housing at all. |
|
| 4755 | 2 | Robert Haydon | | 18 Little Oak Common,, Wanaka, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9305 (blacklabs3865@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51093 | 2.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected |
|
| 4756 | 3 | Private | Christoffel Beukman | 17 Mill End, Rippon Lea, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9305 (piet.beukman@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51094 | 3.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4757 | 4 | independant | alan blyth | unit 1, 10 glasgow street, queenstown, New Zealand, Unknown (abblyth@tpg.com.au) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51095 | 4.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal should not be mandatory. |
| 51096 | 4.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal should be voluntary. |
| 51097 | 4.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the market should not carry these imposts. |
|
| 4758 | 5 | Graeme Edwards | | 12 Old Homestead Place, Kawarau Falls, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9300 (graeme.edwards@azion.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51098 | 5.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended to reflect the economic realities of the post covid environment. |
| 51099 | 5.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the introduction of the proposal be delayed until supply chains are resolved and building inflation has moderated. |
|
| 4759 | 6 | Rahul Doshi | | 11 Clearview Street, Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand, 2014 (info@rainbowcorner.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51100 | 6.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4760 | 7 | Kim Harvey | | 12 Old Homestead Place, Kawarau Falls, New Zealand, 9300 (kim.harvey@youngandhealthy.org.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51101 | 7.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That existing single lots be removed from the scope of the proposal. |
| 51102 | 7.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal only apply to new subdivisions. |
|
| 4761 | 8 | LandEscape Wanaka | Rik Deaton | 93 Camp Hill Road, RD 2, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9382 (ops@landescape-wanaka.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50252 | 8.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.2 Objectives and Policies | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51103 | 8.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That developments such as LandEscape Wanaka which intend to provide similar affordable housing be exempt. |
|
| 4762 | 9 | Castle Island Trustees Ltd | Sarah Pilcher Twiss | PO Box 12291, Meadowbank, Auckland, New Zealand, 1642 (twissnz@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51104 | 9.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51105 | 9.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended to give the developers a mechanism to invest, not gift, to fund the affordable housing projects. |
| 51106 | 9.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the sale or resale of the affordable houses is regulated for the life of the house or as long as the scheme exists. |
| 51107 | 9.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended so that building decent affordable rental stock will be owned by council or regulated landlords for locals to have very long tenure with fixed or controlled rent. |
| 51108 | 9.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended so that some affordable housing created be able to accommodate hospitality and tourism workers for shorter term and with more flexibility. |
|
| 4763 | 10 | Momentum Projects Limited | Shane Fairmaid | 89 Starvation Hill Road, Oxford , Canterbury , New Zealand, 7495 (shanef@momentumprojects.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51109 | 10.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4764 | 11 | Trish Walker | | 323B Hobsonville Road, West Harbour, AUCKLAND, West Harbour, AUCKLAND, New Zealand, 0618 (trish@cwe-ltd.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51110 | 11.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4765 | 12 | Paul Carroll | | 3 Infinity Drive, Wanaka, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9305 (paul.desmond.carroll@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50295 | 12.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the variation be rejected. |
| 51111 | 12.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That funding for affordable housing be placed across the whole community via rates. |
| 51112 | 12.3 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51113 | 12.4 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the funding for affordable housing be allocated within the general council budget. |
|
| 4766 | 13 | Robert Smith | | New Zealand, (robby1133@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51114 | 13.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4767 | 14 | Josh Brinkmann | | New Zealand, (joshua.brinkmann@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50296 | 14.1 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.2 | | Oppose | That the contribution should be required prior to the issue of a 224(c). |
| 50297 | 14.2 | 40.7.1 Discretionary Activities > 40.7.1.1 The amount of the contribution | | Oppose | That 40.7.1.1 be rejected. |
| 50298 | 14.3 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.2 | | Support | That the provision is supported. |
| 50299 | 14.4 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.3 | | Oppose | That 40.6.3 be rejected. |
| 50300 | 14.5 | 40.7.1 Discretionary Activities > 40.7.1.5 Alternative forms of contribution | | Oppose | That 40.7.1.5 be rejected. |
| 50301 | 14.6 | 40.5 Rules - Activities > 40.5.1 | | Oppose | That 40.5.1 be rejected. |
| 50302 | 14.7 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.3 Other Provisions and Rules | | Support | That 40.3 be retained as notified. |
| 50303 | 14.8 | 3.3 Strategic Policies > 3.3.54 | | Oppose | That 3.3.54 be rejected. |
| 50304 | 14.9 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.1 | | Oppose | That 14.2.1.1 be rejected. |
| 50305 | 14.10 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.4 | | Oppose | That if a valuation is required, that council should pay for the valuation, or alternatively that the cost of the valuation be deducted from the contribution charge. |
| 50306 | 14.11 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.6 | | Oppose | That 40.2.1.6 be rejected. |
| 50307 | 14.12 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.5 | | Oppose | That 40.2.1.5 be rejected. |
| 50308 | 14.13 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.2 | | Oppose | That 40.2.1.2 be rejected. |
| 50309 | 14.14 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.8 | | Support | That 40.2.1.8 be rejected. |
| 50310 | 14.15 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.4 | | Oppose | That 40.4.4 be rejected. |
| 50311 | 14.16 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.3 Other Provisions and Rules | | Oppose | That 40.7.1.4 be rejected. |
| 50312 | 14.17 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules | | Oppose | That 40.6.2 be rejected. |
| 50313 | 14.18 | Eligibility > 40.8.1.2 | | Oppose | That 40.8.1.2 be rejected. |
| 50314 | 14.19 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.1 | | Oppose | That 40.6.1.1 be rejected. |
| 50315 | 14.20 | 3.3 Strategic Policies > 3.3.52 | | Oppose | That 3.3.52 be rejected. |
| 50316 | 14.21 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.7 | | Support | That 40.2.1.7 be retained as notified. |
| 50317 | 14.22 | 40.7 Assessment Matters > 40.7.1 Discretionary Activities | | Oppose | That 40.7.1 be rejected. |
| 50318 | 14.23 | 40.7.1 Discretionary Activities > 40.7.1.3 Off-site provisions | | Oppose | That 40.7.1.3 be rejected. |
| 50319 | 14.24 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.1 | | Oppose | That 40.4.1 be rejected. |
| 50320 | 14.25 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.6 | | Support | That 40.4.6 be retained as notified. |
| 50321 | 14.26 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.8 Schedule 40.1 | | Oppose | That schedule 40.1 be rejected |
| 50322 | 14.27 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.1 | | Oppose | That 40.2.1.1 be amended to exclude new home builds and retain subdivisions. |
| 50323 | 14.28 | Retention Mechanism > 40.8.1.1 | | Oppose | That 40.8.1.1 be rejected. |
| 50324 | 14.29 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.7 | | Oppose | That if financial contributions are required, that the funds must go to affordable housing. |
| 50325 | 14.30 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.3 | | Oppose | That 40.4.3 be rejected. |
| 50326 | 14.31 | 40.7 Assessment Matters > 40.7.1 Discretionary Activities | | Oppose | That 40.7.1 be rejected. |
| 50327 | 14.32 | 40.5 Rules - Activities > 40.5.2 | | Oppose | That 40.5.2 be rejected. |
| 50328 | 14.33 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.2 Objectives and Policies | | Support | That 40.2 be retained as notified. |
| 50329 | 14.34 | Affordability > 40.8.1.3 | | Oppose | That 40.8.1.3 be rejected. |
| 50330 | 14.35 | 3.2 Strategic Objective > 3.2.1.10 | | Oppose | That 3.2.1.10 be rejected. |
| 50331 | 14.36 | 40.7.1 Discretionary Activities > 40.7.1.2 Land versus monetary contribution | | Oppose | That 40.7.1.2 be rejected. |
| 50332 | 14.37 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.7 Assessment Matters | | Oppose | That 40.7 be rejected. |
| 50333 | 14.38 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.3 Strategic Policies | | Oppose | That 3.3 be rejected. |
| 50334 | 14.39 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.3 | | Support | That 40.6.1.3 be retained as notified. |
| 50335 | 14.40 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposed changes to chapter 3 be rejected. |
| 50336 | 14.41 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.2 | | Oppose | That 40.6.1.2 be rejected. |
| 50337 | 14.42 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the council should be incentivising building to add to the pool of available housing. |
| 50338 | 14.43 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.3 | | Oppose | That 40.2.1.3 be rejected. |
| 50339 | 14.44 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules | | Oppose | That 40.4 be rejected. |
| 50340 | 14.45 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.6 Rules - Standards | | Oppose | That 40.6 be rejected. |
| 50341 | 14.46 | 3.3 Strategic Policies > 3.3.53 | | Oppose | That 3.3.53 be rejected. |
| 50342 | 14.47 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.4 | | Support | That 40.2.1.4 be retained as notified. |
| 50343 | 14.48 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.2 Strategic Objective | | Oppose | That 3.2 be rejected. |
| 50344 | 14.49 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.5 Rules - Activities | | Oppose | That 40.5 be rejected. |
| 52266 | 14.50 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.5 | | Oppose | That 40.4.5 be rejected. |
|
| 4768 | 15 | Anna Ryder | | Apartment 415, Toru Apartments, 10 Copper Beech Avenue, Frankton, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9300 (anna.ryder.nz@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50345 | 15.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.3 Strategic Policies | | Support | That the proposal is supported in principle. |
| 51115 | 15.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended to exclude contribution requirements for new builds for owner occupiers, but require contribution requirements for investment or secondary houses. |
|
| 4769 | 16 | Gerrit Heezen | | 55b Marina Drive, Frankton, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9300 (gerritanddi@hotmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51116 | 16.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4770 | 17 | Charlotte Pringle | | 107A Atley Road, Queenstown, Arthurs Point, New Zealand, 9371 (charlienathan44@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51117 | 17.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4771 | 18 | Nathan Pringle | | PO BOX 116, Queenstown, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9348 (njblocklaying@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50346 | 18.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4772 | 19 | Ian Macgregor | | Unknown, New Zealand, Unknown (mac.redwine10@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50347 | 19.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4773 | 20 | Ian Moore | | PO Box 2788, Wakatipu, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9349 (scrambler2@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50348 | 20.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51118 | 20.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal should be amended to avoid unsustainably making housing artificially cheap. |
|
| 4774 | 21 | Brooke Clark | | 219 Stone Street, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9305 (baclark167@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51119 | 21.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the proposal is supported. |
| 51120 | 21.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51121 | 21.3 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4775 | 22 | Campbell Black | | 14 KILKELLY CLOSE, TAWA, , WELLINGTON, WELLINGTON, New Zealand, 5028 (campbellblack@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50349 | 22.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected |
| 52337 | 22.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected |
|
| 4776 | 23 | Private | Richard Carter | PO Box 832, Queenstown, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9348 (kiaora080188@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50350 | 23.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Support | That the overall direction of providing affordable housing is supported. |
| 51122 | 23.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That developers be required to produce a certain percentage of affordable housing in their developments, whether as standalone housing, or short term/rentable type accommodation such as large apartment blocks. |
| 51123 | 23.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the developer be given substantial concessions to build apartment style buildings which would suit lower budgets but kept in sync with the overall style and look of the Queenstown basin. |
|
| 4777 | 24 | D Cocks | | Unknown, New Zealand, Unknown (thedogderekc@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51124 | 24.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51125 | 24.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be revisited and restrain from the ambition to be the first in the country. |
| 51126 | 24.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the tax be applied only to land uplifted from rural zone to residential/lifestyle etc. |
| 51127 | 24.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That separate to this proposal that alternative options to address accommodation and housing affordability issues be investigated such as a rate to generate a funding source for QLCHT targeted to vacant holiday homes. |
| 51128 | 24.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the visitor accommodation rules be reviewed as an alternate option to this proposal. |
|
| 4778 | 25 | Bruce Williams | | 24C Douglas Street, Queenstown, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9300 (brubyn@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51129 | 25.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51130 | 25.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That a new set of provisions be inserted as follows:
For an existing lot that does have a house on it, a replacement dwelling on the lot would not trigger the requirement.
However, an infill development where more than one house replaces the existing house, then the contribution would be required for the additional dwelling(s) once the rules are in effect.
For existing houses on the same existing lot that once subdivided into their appropriate separate lots/titles it would not trigger the requirement until any additional non-replacement housing is approved. |
| 51131 | 25.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended to exclude infill development subdivisions. |
|
| 4779 | 26 | murray Frost | | 43 Penrith Park Drive, Wanaka, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9305 (murrayfrostdn@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50351 | 26.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules | | Oppose | That 40.4 be deleted. |
| 50352 | 26.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.2 Objectives and Policies | | Oppose | That the provision is amended to reflect other parts of this submission. |
| 50353 | 26.3 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the changes to Chapter 3 be deleted. |
| 50354 | 26.4 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.3 Strategic Policies | | Oppose | That 3.3 be deleted. |
| 50355 | 26.5 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.2 Strategic Objective | | Support | That 3.2 is supported in principle. |
| 50356 | 26.6 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be amended by cancelling the charges for zoned residential land. |
| 50357 | 26.7 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules | | Oppose | That any tax should be shared on non-zoned land with other parties benefiting (e.g. increased commercial rates). |
| 52191 | 26.8 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the tax be reduced on non-zoned land to avoid or at least reduce extra cost to other purchasers. |
| 52192 | 26.9 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the whole strategy is reviewed to assess effectiveness given the very small number of houses provided in the last 15 years. |
| 52193 | 26.10 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That 40.1 is rejected. |
| 52194 | 26.11 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.8 Schedule 40.1 | | Oppose | That the schedule is rejected. |
|
| 4780 | 27 | N/A | Robert Barr | 98 Main Road, Luggate, New Zealand, 9383 (robsmailbox65@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51132 | 27.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
| 51133 | 27.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That private developers be encouraged to introduce new stock not penalised. |
|
| 4781 | 28 | Tony Strain | | 310 Slopehill Road, RD1, QUEENSTOWN, QUEENSTOWN, New Zealand, 9371 (arrow4water@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51134 | 28.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be withdrawn and replaced with a workable solution such as a district plan that enables rather than blocks development. |
| 51135 | 28.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the cost of affordable housing be carried by the businesses that are creating the demand. |
|
| 4782 | 29 | Craig Walker | | 323B Hobsonville Road, West Harbour, AUCKLAND, West Harbour, AUCKLAND, New Zealand, 0618 (cwe@cwe-ltd.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51136 | 29.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected. |
|
| 4792 | 30 | Jo-Anne & Robert Graves | | PO Box 26, Arrowtown, New Zealand, 9351 (jagdesign@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50571 | 30.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50572 | 30.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50573 | 30.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the homes created within the affordable housing pool be retained and sold back to the affordable housing trust as a first priority. |
| 50574 | 30.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.5 Rules - Activities | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50575 | 30.5 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.3 Strategic Policies | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50576 | 30.6 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.3 Other Provisions and Rules | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50577 | 30.7 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.7 Assessment Matters | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50578 | 30.8 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.2 Objectives and Policies | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50579 | 30.9 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.2 Strategic Objective | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50580 | 30.10 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.6 Rules - Standards | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 50581 | 30.11 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.8 Schedule 40.1 | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
| 52195 | 30.12 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposed revenue source be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential).
|
|
| 4793 | 31 | Sally Garden | | P. O. Box 18, Upper Moutere, New Zealand, 7174 (sallygarden@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing Sally Garden |
|
|
| 51143 | 31.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the variation be rejected. |
| 51144 | 31.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the aspect of the proposal which includes capturing single lot subdivision is rejected. |
| 51145 | 31.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That council land on Ballantyne Road (former oxidation ponds) be used to provide low cost housing. |
| 51146 | 31.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the district plan be reviewed to remove disincentives to provide accommodation. |
| 51147 | 31.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That inclusionary zoning be funded by council rates and/or money received from the Ballantyne Road Oxidation ponds site. |
| 51148 | 31.6 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be considered in light of other taxation, the circumstances of the properties, the property owners as well as current market conditions. |
| 51149 | 31.7 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the unintended consequence of potentially fewer subdivisions occurring also needs to be taken into account. |
|
| 4794 | 32 | Sarah Graves | | 6 Mulbury Way, Lower Shotover, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9304 (sarahgraves1234@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50646 | 32.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.8 Schedule 40.1 | | Oppose | That the proposal be revised to encompass the entire rating base (commercial and residential), not just one targeted source. |
|
| 4795 | 33 | John Glover | | 876 Kinloch Road, Kinloch, New Zealand, 9372 (yetiglover@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51150 | 33.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the plan change is rejected. |
| 51151 | 33.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the Rating Act/development contributions be used. |
| 51152 | 33.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That if the district plan rules are changed, that the rules require a greater range of housing options to come to market for both purchase and rental. |
|
| 4798 | 34 | Otago Regional Council | Warren Hanley | Private Bag 1954, Dunedin, New Zealand, 9054 (warren.hanley@orc.govt.nz) | ORC Submission on Variation to QLDC PDP Inclusionary Housing rules |
|
|
| 51153 | 34.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the proposal is supported in principle for the outcomes being sought. |
|
| 4799 | 35 | Brenda Jessup | | 10 Bridgewater Terrace, Albert Town, New Zealand, 9305 (brenda.jessup@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51154 | 35.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal is rejected. |
| 51155 | 35.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the council tackle the issue of vacant property, find out how many houses in the area are empty most of the year and look at mechanisms to discourage this wasted resource. |
|
| 4801 | 36 | Hayden | Hayden lockhart | 38 Dart Place, Fernhill, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9300 (lockhart.hayden@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50889 | 36.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposal is rejected. |
| 51156 | 36.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That costs should only be added to large scale developments that do not have an allowance for a portion of lower costs. |
| 51157 | 36.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That costs should not be applied to smaller developments and developments that are driving lower cost housing themselves (i.e. urban densification and reduction of oversized luxury sections within the city. |
|
| 4802 | 37 | Ray Ferner | | 26 Mount Hobson Road, Remuera, Auckland, New Zealand, 1050 (rayferner@gmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50890 | 37.1 | 40.5 Rules - Activities > 40.5.1 | | Oppose | That 40.5.1 be rejected. |
| 50891 | 37.2 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.1 | | Oppose | That a general rate levy be applied across the whole community. |
| 50892 | 37.3 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.1 | | Oppose | That a general levy be applied across all properties in the district. |
| 50893 | 37.4 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.1 | | Oppose | That a general levy be applied across all properties in the district. |
| 52197 | 37.5 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.8 | | Oppose | That a rate be applied on all properties. |
|
| 4803 | 38 | Ahana Goormachtigh | | PO Box 2180, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9349 (ahana.goormachtigh@southerndhb.govt.nz) | QLDC_Inclusionary_Zone_PC _2022-11-15-16-42-48 |
|
|
| 51158 | 38.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.2 Strategic Objective | | Support | That the provision is supported. |
| 51159 | 38.2 | 3.2 Strategic Objective > 3.2.1.10 | | Support | That the provision is supported. |
| 51163 | 38.3 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction > 3.3 Strategic Policies | | Support | That the inclusionary zoning components of the strategic direction be retained as notified. |
| 51164 | 38.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the provisions which acknowledge and address factors contributing to adverse outcomes in sustainable resource management and displacement of low-income households is supported. |
| 51166 | 38.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the district-wide chapter is retained as notified. |
| 51167 | 38.6 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the proposed plan of affordable housing in the location which also increases equitable access to resources such as education, public transport and other facilities is supported. |
| 51168 | 38.7 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the purpose, provisions and rules determining the level of financial contribution to be made to the council by most forms of subdivision and development is supported. |
| 51169 | 38.8 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the policies outlining the manner of financial contribution and the objective to utilise these contributions for providing affordable housing for low to moderate income households is supported. |
|
| 4804 | 39 | Alistair Munro | | 22 Worrobil St, North Balgowlah, Sydney, Australia, 2093 (z_munro@hotmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing Submission on Affordable Housing |
|
|
| 51028 | 39.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposed plan change be dealt with at a central government level. |
| 51029 | 39.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That if the proposal is to remain a local government issue, it is dealt with by means of rezoning and rates. |
| 51030 | 39.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal should be rejected |
| 51031 | 39.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the section 32 has not provided proof that central government will not adequately address housing affordability, and this must be addressed. |
| 51032 | 39.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the Section 32 report includes more discussion around using general rates as an option for raising funds. |
| 51087 | 39.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the section 32 needs to provide greater commentary around using general rates to raise funding for inclusionary housing. |
|
| 4806 | 40 | Rachelle Grubb | | 20 Essex Avenue, Winton, Winton, New Zealand, 9720 (grubbfamily@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51088 | 40.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the funding source for the proposed plan change be revised so it takes in the entire rating base (commercial and residential). |
|
| 4807 | 41 | Queenstown Lakes Community Housing Trust | Julie Scott | PO Box 1748, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9348 (julie@qlcht.org.nz) | QLCHT Submission on QLDC Proposed Inclusionary Housing provisions Nov22 |
|
|
| 51089 | 41.1 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.1 | | Oppose | That Rule 40.6.1 (1a.i) provides an exemption for subdivision of a serviced lot in a zone within the urban growth boundary zone, where title was issued prior to this plan change becoming operative, that creates no more than three lots. |
| 51090 | 41.2 | 40.6.1.2 > 40.6.1.2.c | | Oppose | That this rule should be deleted. |
| 51139 | 41.3 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.2 | | Oppose | That there be an exemption to Rule 40.6.1.2 for existing serviced allotments where the record of title was issued prior to the date the plan change becomes operative and where only one residential unit is to be erected on each lot; and an exemption for a dwelling on those lots created pursuant to the Existing Urban Lot Exemption. |
|
| 4809 | 42 | Flora Gilkison | | Unknown, New Zealand, Unknown (floragilkison@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51091 | 42.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposal be rejected, and the geographical areas are reviewed to include Queenstown only. |
|
| 4810 | 43 | Grant Thomas | | New Zealand, (grant_fi@xtra.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50894 | 43.1 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.2 | | Oppose | That all existing titled sections and dwellings are exempted from the proposed financial contribution. |
| 50895 | 43.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That QLDC should seek/advocate for appropriate funding and support from Central Government |
| 50896 | 43.3 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.2 | | Oppose | That financial contributions should be paid prior to issue of Code of Compliance, with payment instalment schemes available. |
| 50897 | 43.4 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.3 | | Oppose | That all existing titled sections and residential property are exempt |
| 50898 | 43.5 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.4 | | Oppose | That valuation should be at the cost of QLDC by a registered valuer (as mutually agreed) and in event of disagreement the applicant can seek an independent valuation and with value being lesser of the two. |
| 51092 | 43.6 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the funding options are reviewed to include business and residents. |
|
| 4811 | 44 | Hayley Mahon | | New Zealand, (hayley@jea.co.nz) | Submission #44 - Hayley Mahon on behalf of RCL Henley Downs Limited |
|
|
| 51137 | 44.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposed plan change be rejected |
| 51140 | 44.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That Chapter 40 is amended to allow for flexibility in methods for contribution to affordable housing. |
| 51141 | 44.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That Chapter 40 be amended to make it clear that Hanley's Farm is not subject to further affordable housing requirements. |
| 51142 | 44.4 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That any other consequential or alternative relief as may be necessary or appropriate to address the issues raised in this submission or give effect to the relief sought, including as a result of changes that may arise from other submissions be included. |
|
| 4813 | 45 | Ahha | Campbell McNeill | 23 The Octagon, Dunedin Central, Dunedin 9016, Dunedin Central, Dunedin, New Zealand, 9016 (campbell@ahha.studio) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50899 | 45.1 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.1 | | Oppose | That Rule 40.6.1 (1.a.i) be amended to exclude lots that are subdivided into two or three from making make a contribution. |
| 50900 | 45.2 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.2 | | Oppose | That Rule 40.6.1.2 be amended to exclude lots that are existing and serviced at the time the plan change becomes operative, from providing a financial contribution. |
| 50901 | 45.3 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.2 | | Oppose | That Rule 40.6.1.2 c be rejected |
| 51138 | 45.4 | 40.6.1.2 > 40.6.1.2.c | | Not Stated | |
|
| 4814 | 46 | Nigel Lloyd | | New Zealand, (nigel@hadleys.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50902 | 46.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That residential infill not associated with development be excluded. |
| 50903 | 46.2 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.1 | | Oppose | I seek the submission to be allowed/disallowed: : Exclude residential infill development not associated with subdivision. The reasons for my support or opposition are: : At least some forms of infill development (in particular those not involving subdivision) should be excluded as these already have the ability to positively impact housing affordability. |
| 50904 | 46.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That residential infill of existing residential properties, particularly when not associated with subdivision be excluded. |
| 50905 | 46.4 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.2 | | Oppose | That residential infill not associated with subdivision be excluded. |
| 50906 | 46.5 | 3.3 Strategic Policies > 3.3.52 | | Support | That 3.3.52 be retained as notified. |
| 50907 | 46.6 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.3 | | Oppose | That an exemption be added to cover additional residential infill dwellings also. |
| 50908 | 46.7 | 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules > 40.4.2 | | Oppose | That the timing be changed to be prior to granting of code of compliance. |
| 51165 | 46.8 | 40.2 Objectives and Policies > 40.2.1.4 | | Oppose | That the provision be extended to include residential dwellings as part of infill development if not associated with a subdivision. |
|
| 4816 | 47 | Richard Kemp | | PO Box 2770, Wakatipu, Queenstown, New Zealand, 9349 (richard@pragmaticplanning.co.nz) | Inclusionary Housing Correspondence With Policy Team (Amy) |
|
|
| 50909 | 47.1 | 40.5 Rules - Activities > 40.5.2 | | Oppose | That a new definition of ' Development' for the purposes of Chapter 40 is inserted into the District Plan. |
| 50910 | 47.2 | 40.6 Rules - Standards > 40.6.1.3 | | Oppose | That Rule 40.6.1.3 is amended to exempt changes to land use within an existing residential unit. |
|
| 4817 | 48 | Marian Krogh | | Unknown, New Zealand, Unknown (mariankrogh@hotmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50911 | 48.1 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Support | That the proposal be accepted. |
| 51191 | 48.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That the proposal needs to go further to address a greater diversity in housing stock, more public and active transport connections, with climate change as a consideration. |
|
| 4818 | 49 | Dan Batchelor | | 31 Settlement Road, Lincoln, New Zealand, 7672 (dan@danbatch.nz) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 50912 | 49.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposed amendments to the district plan are not implemented. |
| 50913 | 49.2 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Support | That the exclusion of the rural zone as notified is supported |
| 50914 | 49.3 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.3 Other Provisions and Rules | | Oppose | That 40.3 is rejected. |
| 50915 | 49.4 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | That the proposed changes to chapter 3 are rejected. |
| 50916 | 49.5 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.5 Rules - Activities | | Oppose | That 40.5 is rejected. |
| 50917 | 49.6 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.6 Rules - Standards | | Oppose | That 40.6 is rejected. |
| 50918 | 49.7 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.4 Interpreting and Applying the Rules | | Oppose | That 40.4 is rejected. |
| 50919 | 49.8 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.1 Purpose | | Oppose | That 40.1 is rejected. |
| 50920 | 49.9 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | I seek the submission to be allowed/disallowed: : The reasons for my support or opposition are: : It will be an ineffective way of providing affordable housing. It is supported that Rural Zone has not been included.
|
| 50921 | 49.10 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing > 40.3 Other Provisions and Rules | | Oppose | I seek the submission to be allowed/disallowed: : The reasons for my support or opposition are: : It will be an ineffective way of providing affordable housing. It is supported that Rural Zone has not been included.
|
| 50922 | 49.11 | Chapter 3: Strategic Direction | | Oppose | I seek the submission to be allowed/disallowed: : The reasons for my support or opposition are: : It will be an ineffective way of providing affordable housing. It is supported that Rural Zone has not been included.
|
|
| 4819 | 50 | Jenny Howe | | 86 Upton Street, Wanaka, New Zealand, 9305 (howej67@hotmail.com) | Inclusionary Housing |
|
|
| 51160 | 50.1 | Chapter 40: Inclusionary Housing | | Oppose | That the proposed plan change be rejected. |
|